Addicted to Toxicity: When Chaos Feels Like Love

JC

Jan 14, 2026By Jaime Coaches

Let’s stop pretending.

If you keep ending up in the same painful dynamics — different person, same emotional hangover — it’s not bad luck.

It’s not that you “just pick the wrong people.”

And it’s definitely not because you love too much.

You’re addicted to toxicity.

Not because you’re weak.
Because your nervous system learned early on that chaos equals connection.

That’s the part no one wants to say out loud.

Toxicity doesn’t always feel toxic

Here’s why this mess is so confusing:
toxic dynamics don’t show up wearing red flags and warning labels.

They show up as:

  • insane chemistry
  • emotional intensity
  • “I’ve never felt this before” energy
  • the push-pull that keeps you checking your phone like a lab rat hitting a lever

And yeah — it can feel amazing.

Your body lights up.
Your thoughts obsess.
Your nervous system mistakes activation for attraction.

That’s not romance.
That’s conditioning.

Two worried interracial friends checking phone

You’re not chasing people — you’re chasing familiarity

Your brain doesn’t care about healthy relationships.
It cares about known ones.

If you grew up around emotional inconsistency, unpredictability, or love that had to be earned, your system learned:

This is what connection feels like.

So when someone mirrors that same emotional frequency later in life, your body recognizes them before your logic does.

Not because they’re special.
Because they’re familiar.

And familiar feels safe — even when it hurts.

The real addiction: emotional intensity

Let’s get real uncomfortable for a second.

Some of us aren’t addicted to people.
We’re addicted to emotional spikes.

The high of being chosen.
The crash of being ignored.
The adrenaline of waiting, hoping, decoding.

It creates a chemical loop:
hope → anxiety → relief → withdrawal → repeat.

That cycle can feel like passion — but it’s closer to a stress response than love.

And until you heal the part of you that confuses intensity with intimacy, calm will feel boring… and healthy will feel wrong.

Romanticizing toxicity is self-betrayal

Here’s the line most people don’t want to cross:

At some point, continuing to choose toxicity stops being unconscious and starts being self-abandonment.

Because you do notice the red flags.
You do feel your body tighten.
You do know when you’re shrinking, chasing, or performing.

But the pull is familiar — and familiarity is seductive.

So we rationalize:
“They’re just avoidant.”
“They’re working on themselves.”
“It’s complicated.”
“I just need to be more patient.”

No.
You’re just replaying an old wound and calling it love.

Why healthy relationships feel dull (at first)

No one tells you this part.

When you start healing, calm can feel terrifying.

Consistency feels suspicious.
Emotional availability feels unfamiliar.
Not having to chase feels anticlimactic.

Your nervous system isn’t broken — it’s detoxing.

And like any detox, the absence of the drug can feel worse before it feels better.

But boring isn’t the opposite of passion.
Dysregulated is.

The truth that changes everything

You don’t stop choosing toxic dynamics by trying harder or “loving better.”

You stop when you finally ask:

Why does this feel like home?

That question cracks everything open.

Because when you heal the part of you that learned love through instability, toxicity loses its grip.

It stops being exciting.
It stops being magnetic.
It stops feeling like chemistry.

And what replaces it isn’t boring — it’s safe, steady, and real.

How to start breaking the cycle (for real) 

Not affirmations. Not manifesting. Actual work.

1. Call the pattern what it is
Not “a deep connection.”
Not “bad timing.”
A pattern.

2. Track how your body feels — not your fantasies
If your attraction comes with anxiety, hyper-fixation, or self-doubt, that’s data.

3. Stop mistaking calm for lack of chemistry
Calm is your nervous system learning a new language.

4. Get curious about your first blueprint for love
Who did you have to chase?
Who was emotionally unavailable?
Who taught you to work for connection?

5. Choose discomfort over dysfunction
Healing doesn’t feel sexy at first.
But neither does repeating the same heartbreak forever.

 
Final truth


You’re not broken.
You’re not too much.
You’re not incapable of healthy love.

You’re just loyal to an old story.

And the moment you decide to stop romanticizing toxicity, everything changes.

Not overnight.
But permanently.

It’s all unfolding perfectly. 

If you saw yourself in this, take that seriously.

Awareness is the first crack in the cycle — but healing is what actually changes who you’re attracted to.

If you want support untangling old attachment patterns, calming your nervous system, and learning what healthy connection actually feels like, I can help.

👉 Learn more about working together and start choosing from a regulated, grounded place.